A mechanic in Cranberry Township, Pennsylvania, faces serious legal consequences after being arrested for allegedly loaning out customer vehicles without permission. Keith Smith, owner of Oilology, reportedly engaged in a scheme that involved giving customers’ cars to others as loaner vehicles. The situation came to light when a victim discovered his car had accumulated an additional 5,000 miles after being returned to him.
The victim, who had taken his 2011 Suzuki Kazashi to Oilology in June, expressed disbelief at the extra mileage and damage incurred during the unauthorized loaning. “There’s a lot of people who he’s done it to,” the victim told WXPI 11 News. “I didn’t expect him to do this to me, even though he has his past.” This incident is not an isolated case; Smith has a history of similar offenses, with at least eleven previous victims who have come forward.
Smith’s legal troubles date back to March 2023, when he was placed on probation for related charges. Following a probation violation hearing on December 5, 2023, Smith awaits trial while currently in jail. Upon his release, he will be required to wear an electronic monitor, refrain from conducting any business, and maintain distance from the Oilology property, which now bears a closed sign as the landlord plans to sell it.
The ramifications of Smith’s actions extend beyond legal issues. Victims are left facing diminished vehicle value, increased mileage, and additional wear and tear. When asked if he understood the gravity of his actions, Smith responded, “Absolutely not.”
Instances of mechanic misconduct are not limited to Pennsylvania. In another notable case, a woman in Australia experienced a similar violation of trust when her new Ford Focus RS was taken by a local mechanic for personal use without her consent. Dashcam footage revealed the mechanic driving the vehicle to a fast-food restaurant and parking it overnight at his home. Although this incident did not result in criminal charges, it highlights the need for vigilance when entrusting vehicles to mechanics.
To protect against unauthorized use of vehicles, customers can take several precautions. One effective measure is to document the mileage at the time of drop-off, creating a record that can serve as evidence if discrepancies arise. Additionally, placing an Airtag in the vehicle allows owners to track its location in real time, offering peace of mind. Many modern vehicles also feature smartphone integrations, enabling owners to monitor their vehicles remotely.
While these strategies cannot entirely prevent misuse, they can help vehicle owners remain informed about their cars’ whereabouts. As the case against Keith Smith unfolds, it serves as a stark reminder of the importance of selecting trustworthy mechanics and safeguarding personal property.
