UPDATE: Despite scathing reviews, viewers are flocking to Ryan Murphy’s new Disney+ series, All’s Fair, which features a star-studded cast including Kim Kardashian and Naomi Watts. Critics have labeled the show a “clumsy, condescending girlboss fantasia,” with an initial 0% rating on Rotten Tomatoes, but audience reactions are surprisingly positive.
The legal drama follows Allura Grant (Kardashian) and Liberty Ronson (Watts) as they leave a male-dominated law firm to establish their own practice with the motto “Women representing women, only.” Their mentor Dina Standish, portrayed by Glenn Close, supports their venture but tensions rise with another lawyer, Carrington “Carr” Lane (Sarah Paulson), who vows revenge after being left behind.
As the first three episodes unfold, audiences are treated to a mix of humor and drama, with celebrity guest appearances from Judith Light, Jessica Simpson, and Elizabeth Berkley. The personal turmoil of Allura, whose husband Chase (Matthew Noszka) is unfaithful, adds layers to the storyline.
Critics may highlight moments that evoke popular reality shows, likening the writing to Selling Sunset, but many viewers find this aspect entertaining. The show is described as a guilty pleasure, perfect for those looking to escape reality. One viewer tweeted, “#AllsFair is a cute show. Light and funny,” capturing the sentiment of many who enjoy its over-the-top drama.
The show’s cinematic quality and vibrant soundtrack, featuring hits from Janet Jackson and Doja Cat, enhance the viewing experience. Even with the controversy, Anthony Hemingway, who directed episodes two and three, defended the series, stating, “It may not be for you, and that’s OK,” reinforcing that entertainment doesn’t have to be serious to be enjoyable.
In social media reactions, fans are defending the show against critics, emphasizing the fun and engaging nature of its plot. “I seen so many bad reviews about #AllsFair but I’m loving it. It’s a cute girly show,” one user shared, showcasing the divided opinions surrounding the series.
While All’s Fair may not win awards for critical acclaim, its allure lies in its ability to entertain and draw viewers in with its campy charm. The show is now streaming on Disney+, with new episodes releasing weekly on Tuesdays.
As the debate continues, will the negative reviews deter viewers from tuning in? It appears not, as audiences are increasingly eager to see just how deep the drama goes.
Don’t miss out—catch the first four episodes of All’s Fair streaming now on Disney+!
