Councillor Stephen Leask has issued a warning that reversing the decision to construct a new school in Brae would not only be a “complete embarrassment” but could also incur significant financial implications. As preparations for the project continue, Leask emphasized that it would be “incredibly foolish” for councillors to abandon their commitment at this stage.
The new Brae school project is currently advancing towards a full business case, which is expected to be presented to councillors for final approval in October 2026. Earlier this year, in January 2024, the council agreed to move forward with the project, which is projected to cost approximately £4.5 million to reach this critical stage. If everything goes according to plan, construction could begin in November 2026, with the school anticipated to open its doors to students in August 2028.
The current estimated budget for the new school stands at £42.5 million, which encompasses the costs associated with reaching the full business case. The Scottish Government has pledged to contribute half of this funding over a 25-year period.
During a recent council meeting, Dennis Leask, chairman of the development committee, expressed concerns regarding the proposed timeline, describing it as “optimistic.” He pointed out that construction is set to kick off just a month after the full business case is expected to be approved. Furthermore, he raised the question of whether the Shetland Islands Council (SIC) would be liable for expenses incurred prior to the approval of the full business case.
SIC Chief Executive Maggie Sandison clarified that a decision has already been made to progress to the full business case stage, which inherently involves some costs. She also noted that there is a “clear separation” between the costs incurred to reach this stage and those associated with the execution of the business case itself.
Leask urged his colleagues to avoid any reversal of previous decisions, stating that such a move would result in “considerable cost to the council” and could lead to “reputational damage.” He expressed his desire to see the project continue until the necessary grants from the Scottish Government are secured for its construction.
Following the meeting, SIC leader Emma Macdonald, who represents the Shetland North ward that includes Brae, reiterated her support for the new school project. She emphasized the importance of the school to local families and stated that all councillors would receive the necessary information to make an informed decision on the full business case in October. “The Brae school serves a wide catchment area and is important to the future of many families,” Macdonald said.
Earlier this year, Robertson Construction Group was announced as the preferred main contractor for the project. Initial designs have already been unveiled, and public consultations have taken place. Plans suggest that the new school could be constructed on the site of the existing grass pitch, with intentions to demolish the current building. The area would potentially see a reinstated pitch following the demolition.
As the project progresses, it remains to be seen how the council will navigate the financial and reputational stakes involved in the future of the Brae school.
