Plans by the Brighton, Hove and Sussex VI Form College (BHASVIC) to install an artificial sports pitch on its playing field have sparked significant community objections. A public meeting held recently drew over 30 attendees who expressed environmental concerns regarding the potential impact of the proposed project.
Among the primary issues raised were fears about the loss of biodiversity and the effects of planned floodlights on local wildlife, including insects, birds, and bats. Steve Geliot, vice-chair of the concerned group and an environmental campaigner, highlighted that the 4,000k white colour spectrum of the floodlights poses a risk to these species. He stated, “We are highlighting the biodiversity impacts, the light pollution, the detrimental visual impacts on Dyke Road Park due to 4.5-metre steel fencing and 10-metre-high light columns.”
Geliot further noted that while the project includes proposals for biodiversity net gain (BNG) sourced from the Iford estate, he believes this approach effectively exports biodiversity out of the city. He cited the work of ecologist Graeme Lyons, who has documented 500 species in the field, including 11 with conservation status.
Concerns were echoed by members of the Friends of the Park, who questioned the necessity of additional sports facilities given that similar amenities exist at the nearby Cardinal Newman Catholic School. With a current student body of nearly 4,000, they argued that the proposed facilities would primarily benefit “elite” sports teams without providing broader opportunities for all students. Noise issues were also mentioned, particularly in relation to the Brighton Open Air Theatre, prompting BHASVIC to conduct additional noise tests.
In response to the objections, BHASVIC principal William Baldwin defended the development, asserting that it will deliver a net gain in biodiversity as outlined in the planning documents. “We have completed extensive ecological surveys in order to submit our plans with appropriate mitigations in place to minimise the impact of this work,” Baldwin stated. He emphasized the college’s commitment to enhancing the biodiversity of the community area surrounding the playing fields.
Baldwin also highlighted the college’s accomplishments in sports, noting that the ladies’ football academy recently reached the semi-finals of the National Colleges Cup and the netball academy advanced to the finals of the National Schools U-19 competition. He pointed out that currently, students must travel off-site for practical classes, training, and matches, thus underscoring the need for improved facilities.
The application has garnered considerable attention on the website of Brighton and Hove City Council, with 1,350 objections and 78 supportive comments logged thus far. Those wishing to view the application or voice their opinions can do so by searching for BH2025/02901 on the council’s website.
As the debate continues, the outcome of BHASVIC’s plans will depend on the balancing act between community concerns and the college’s ambitions for sports development.
